HM Revenue and Customs Brief 40/09
Submit Articles Back to Articles
Issued 14 July 2009
VAT: The decision of the High Court in respect of Rank (mechanised cash
bingo and gaming machines)
The High Court issued its decision in this case on 8 June 2009 – the judgment
being in Rank’s favour. It confirmed that there had been a breach of fiscal
neutrality in the tax treatment of the supply of mechanised cash bingo (MCB).
This means that participation fees for playing MCB should have been exempt from
VAT and businesses can now submit claims to HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) for
repayment of any output tax wrongly accounted for, subject to the guidelines
In relation to gaming machines, the High Court judgment relates to an appeal
against an interim ruling of the VAT Tribunal. As the Tribunal has not yet ruled
in respect of Rank’s full appeal, HMRC will not at this time consider any claims
relating to this issue.
Rank, which operates Mecca bingo halls, claimed there had been
inconsistencies in the way VAT had been applied to the participation fees
customers paid to play MCB and to the takings of gaming machines.
Last year the VAT Tribunal ruled there had been a breach of fiscal neutrality
in the case of MCB as some participation fees were taxed while others were
exempt. (Fiscal neutrality means that similar supplies must be treated the same
for tax purposes to avoid any distortion of competition). The High Court has
agreed with the Tribunal’s decision that all participation fees for MCB should
have been exempt from VAT.
The VAT Tribunal also issued an interim decision regarding the way HMRC taxed
gaming machines, stating there had been a breach of fiscal neutrality in some
cases and over a short period of time before the law was changed in December
Implications of this judgment
HMRC will now consider claims for output tax wrongly accounted for by bingo
operators on MCB participation fees.
As bingo duty is charged on the VAT-exclusive value of participation fees,
this judgment will have an effect on bingo duty declarations although HMRC is
still considering the precise implications. However, HMRC will now enforce those
bingo duty assessments already made. Further assessments to bingo duty may be
made as appropriate.
As the gaming machine case is continuing, with a VAT Tribunal hearing later
this year, HMRC will not credit any claims on this issue.
Making claims or adjustments
Where a business wishes to make a claim to HMRC for output tax wrongly
accounted for in respect of MCB participation fees, they may do so, although
evidence must be produced that output tax was accounted for, to substantiate the
All claims will be subject to the four-year time limit in section 80(4) of
the VAT Act 1994 (as amended) and no claim for periods ending on or prior to 31
March 2006 will be considered.
Correcting the error on your VAT return
Overdeclarations of output tax can also be corrected by adjusting the current
VAT return if the net amount of all errors in the accounting periods being
- £10,000 or less; or
- less than £50,000 and less than 1 per cent of the box 6 figure on the VAT
return in which the adjustment is being effected
These de minimis levels apply to the entire ‘claim’. Thus if your ‘claim’ is
for ten accounting periods, it is the net overdeclaration for all ten periods
that must be within these levels.
Under regulation 34(1A) of the VAT Regulations 1995 (as amended), all
adjustments must be made within four years after the end of the accounting
period in which the overdeclaration was made but no accounting period can be
adjusted if it ended on or before 31 March 2006.
Details of where to send your claim can be obtained from update 2 to VAT
Notice 700/45 - How to correct VAT errors and make adjustments or claims from
the HM Revenue & Customs National Advice Service on 0845 010 9000.
HMRC may reject all or part of a claim if repayment would unjustly enrich the
claimant. More details on ‘unjust enrichment’ can be found at part 14 of VAT
Notice 700/45 How to correct VAT errors and make adjustments or claims.
There may be direct tax implications where amounts of overdeclared output tax
are repaid to businesses and your attention is drawn to R&C Brief 14/09 issued
Where you are in any doubt about the correct treatment please contact the
National Advice Service.
About the Author
© Crown Copyright 2009.
A licence is need to reproduce this article and has been republished for
educational / informational purposes only. Article reproduced by permission of
HM Revenue & Customs under the terms of a Click-Use Licence. Tax briefs are
updated regularly and may be out of date at time of reading.
Follow us @Scopulus_News
Article Published/Sorted/Amended on Scopulus 2009-07-18 21:32:34 in Tax Articles